New Listing

In-Person: 10/03 12:00 PM - 2:00 PM

$2,475,000

$13,286 est/mo Sourced by Back At You

1212 Olivia Street,KEY WEST, FL 33040

KEY WEST, FL 33040

Description

Discover the charm of what was once a carriage house and now a single-level home nestled in the highly desirable Meadows neighborhood of Old Town Key West. This inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bath residence blends historic character with modern updates, offering the quintessential island lifestyle. Effortless indoor-outdoor living defines this home, which features an open, airy feel that flows seamlessly to a private backyard oasis. The renovated kitchen features quartz countertops, modern finishes perfect for entertaining or everyday living. A versatile bonus loft provides the ideal space for a home office. Step outside to your own tropical retreat, complete with a sparkling pool surrounded by a spacious brick patio, cabana bar, fabulous outdoor shower and mature landscaping that creates privacy and a lush island ambiance. Topped off with off-street parking, whole house generator, x flood zone and close proximity to everything that makes Key West living so special, while still providing a peaceful neighborhood setting. This is truly a gem waiting to become your tropical island home!

Details

MLS #	621462
Listing Type	For Sale
Style	House
Sub-Type	Resale
Status	Active
Year	1976
Days On Site	3
Listing Provided By	Truman & Co. (KW) \| Wendy L Zintsmaster

Features

Bed(s)	3
Bath(s)	2 Total
SQ Feet	1,750
Pool	Yes
Zoning	HMDR - Historic Medium Density R
Acreage	0.10
Water Front	None
Property View	No Waterview

Taxes

Property	14934

Area Information

State	FL
County	Monroe
City	KEY WEST
Zip Code	33040
Area	01 Key West
Community Name	W C Maloney Diagram (2.0)
Listing VS Median (in W C Maloney Diagram (2.0))
Price: $2,475,000 low \| high Med: $5,000 100% of Average sqft: 1,750 low \| high Med: 900 98.571428571429% of Average $ / sqft: $1,414 low \| high Med: $6 100% of Average On site: 3 low \| high Med: 468 2% of Average

Sourced by Back At You

Market Activity 33040

Date	Sales	Avg $ Per SqFt	Min Sale Price	Max Sale Price	Med Sale Price
Date: Sep 2026	Sales: 2	Avg $ Per SqFt: $786.21	Min Sale Price: $1,000,000	Max Sale Price: $1,550,000	Med Sale Price: $1,275,000
Date: Aug 2026	Sales: 9	Avg $ Per SqFt: $895.24	Min Sale Price: $600,000	Max Sale Price: $2,150,000	Med Sale Price: $1,340,000
Date: Jul 2026	Sales: 17	Avg $ Per SqFt: $769.93	Min Sale Price: $335,000	Max Sale Price: $1,965,000	Med Sale Price: $830,000
Date: Jun 2026	Sales: 19	Avg $ Per SqFt: $921.52	Min Sale Price: $22,678	Max Sale Price: $5,800,000	Med Sale Price: $875,000
Date: May 2026	Sales: 26	Avg $ Per SqFt: $900.56	Min Sale Price: $480,000	Max Sale Price: $5,000,000	Med Sale Price: $1,062,500
Date: Apr 2026	Sales: 24	Avg $ Per SqFt: $848.83	Min Sale Price: $285,000	Max Sale Price: $4,250,000	Med Sale Price: $1,052,500
Date: Mar 2026	Sales: 35	Avg $ Per SqFt: $911.23	Min Sale Price: $305,000	Max Sale Price: $7,250,000	Med Sale Price: $825,000
Date: Feb 2026	Sales: 37	Avg $ Per SqFt: $924.64	Min Sale Price: $55,000	Max Sale Price: $22,000,100	Med Sale Price: $1,000,000
Date: Jan 2026	Sales: 64	Avg $ Per SqFt: $1017.72	Min Sale Price: $173,500	Max Sale Price: $4,225,000	Med Sale Price: $1,325,000
Date: Dec 2025	Sales: 28	Avg $ Per SqFt: $969.24	Min Sale Price: $80,000	Max Sale Price: $4,300,000	Med Sale Price: $1,335,000
Date: Nov 2025	Sales: 30	Avg $ Per SqFt: $995.47	Min Sale Price: $285,000	Max Sale Price: $7,200,000	Med Sale Price: $922,500
Date: Oct 2025	Sales: 38	Avg $ Per SqFt: $850.53	Min Sale Price: $3,453	Max Sale Price: $5,400,000	Med Sale Price: $991,000

Sourced by Back At You

Sep 2026
Sales:	2
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$786.21
Min Sale Price:	$1,000,000
Max Sale Price:	$1,550,000
Med Sale Price:	$1,275,000
Aug 2026
Sales:	9
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$895.24
Min Sale Price:	$600,000
Max Sale Price:	$2,150,000
Med Sale Price:	$1,340,000
Jul 2026
Sales:	17
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$769.93
Min Sale Price:	$335,000
Max Sale Price:	$1,965,000
Med Sale Price:	$830,000
Jun 2026
Sales:	19
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$921.52
Min Sale Price:	$22,678
Max Sale Price:	$5,800,000
Med Sale Price:	$875,000
May 2026
Sales:	26
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$900.56
Min Sale Price:	$480,000
Max Sale Price:	$5,000,000
Med Sale Price:	$1,062,500
Apr 2026
Sales:	24
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$848.83
Min Sale Price:	$285,000
Max Sale Price:	$4,250,000
Med Sale Price:	$1,052,500
Mar 2026
Sales:	35
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$911.23
Min Sale Price:	$305,000
Max Sale Price:	$7,250,000
Med Sale Price:	$825,000
Feb 2026
Sales:	37
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$924.64
Min Sale Price:	$55,000
Max Sale Price:	$22,000,100
Med Sale Price:	$1,000,000
Jan 2026
Sales:	64
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$1017.72
Min Sale Price:	$173,500
Max Sale Price:	$4,225,000
Med Sale Price:	$1,325,000
Dec 2025
Sales:	28
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$969.24
Min Sale Price:	$80,000
Max Sale Price:	$4,300,000
Med Sale Price:	$1,335,000
Nov 2025
Sales:	30
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$995.47
Min Sale Price:	$285,000
Max Sale Price:	$7,200,000
Med Sale Price:	$922,500
Oct 2025
Sales:	38
Avg $ Per SqFt:	$850.53
Min Sale Price:	$3,453
Max Sale Price:	$5,400,000
Med Sale Price:	$991,000

Request a showing

MLS Internet Data Exchange (IDX) information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Florida Keys Board of Realtors.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site come s in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of REALTORS®, Inc. MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Schmitt are marked with the MLS logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker’s office.

Contact

Learn More About This Property

Lela O. Ashkarian

Coldwell Banker Schmitt

622790 ABR, CRS, GRI, E-PRO, C2X (305) 395-0814 lela@cbschmitt.com

Open House
In-Person 10/03 12:00 PM - 2:00 PM

State	FL
County	Monroe
City	KEY WEST
Zip Code	33040
Area	01 Key West
Community Name	W C Maloney Diagram (2.0)
Listing VS Median (in W C Maloney Diagram (2.0))
Price: $2,475,000 low \| high Med: $5,000 100% of Average sqft: 1,750 low \| high Med: 900 98.571428571429% of Average $ / sqft: $1,414 low \| high Med: $6 100% of Average On site: 3 low \| high Med: 468 2% of Average

Sourced by Back At You

Nearby Listings (Within 1/4 mile)

Price: $1.856M - $3.93M

sqft: 1,000 - 2,000

Nearby Listings Property Image	Nearby Listings Details
	$1,899,000 1513 Pine Street Key West, FL 33040
	$2,449,000 1320 Eliza Street Key West, FL 33040
	$2,550,000 1017 Angela Street Key West, FL 33040

Listing Updated: October 1, 2026 at 8:34:22 AM PDT

1212 Olivia Street,KEY WEST, FL 33040

KEY WEST, FL 33040

Description

Details

Features

Taxes

Area Information

Market Activity 33040

Request a showing

Request a showing

Contact

Additional Information

Showing Information

Submit Form

Contact

Learn More About This Property

Lela O. Ashkarian

Coldwell Banker Schmitt

Contact

Additional Information

Submit Form

Attachments

Loading

$1,899,000

$2,449,000

$2,550,000

Lilas Ashkarian - Coldwell Banker

1212 Olivia Street,KEY WEST, FL 33040

KEY WEST, FL 33040

Share:

Description

Details

Features

Taxes

Area Information

Market Activity 33040

Request a showing

Request a showing

Contact

Additional Information

Showing Information

Submit Form

Contact

Learn More About This Property

Lela O. Ashkarian

Coldwell Banker Schmitt

Contact

Additional Information

Submit Form

Attachments

Loading

$1,899,000

$2,449,000

$2,550,000

Lilas Ashkarian - Coldwell Banker